I Tried Martha Stewart’s Meal Kit So You Don’t Have To: An Honest Marley Spoon Review (2025)

This post contains affiliate links. If you click on them (like the photos or buttons below) and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps keep the kitchen running and allows me to keep testing meal kits for you!

Let’s be real for a second. Is there anything worse than the grocery store at 5:30 PM on a Tuesday? The fluorescent lights, the squeaky cart wheel, the realization that you forgot the one ingredient you actually came for?

I used to handle “dinner” by staring into my fridge until a rotisserie chicken magically appeared, or inevitably ordering takeout that cost way too much and arrived lukewarm.

Enter Marley Spoon.

You’ve probably heard of it. It’s the meal kit stamped with the approval of the domestic goddess herself, Martha Stewart. But does it actually taste good, or is it just fancy branding? I ordered a box to find out if it could turn my chaotic kitchen into a sanctuary of flavor.

Spoiler Alert: My delivery guy is now my favorite person on earth.

What Exactly IS Marley Spoon?

Think of Marley Spoon as your personal sous-chef who does all the boring stuff (shopping, chopping, measuring) and leaves you with the fun part (cooking and eating).

Unlike other kits that give you “basic” meals, this one is designed to be a bit more elevated. We’re talking fresh herbs, unique spices, and recipes that make you feel like you attended culinary school, even if you usually burn toast.

Here’s what it looked like when it arrived on my doorstep:

Here’s the rundown:

• The Menu: They have over 100+ recipes per week. Yes, one hundred. Vegan, family-friendly, low carb—they have it all.
• The Quality: This is where they flex. The produce is crisp, the meats are quality, and the sauces are legit.
• The Effort: Most meals take 30-40 minutes. It’s “fast food” without the guilt.

How It Works (The “Idiot-Proof” Test)

I am not a professional chef. I am a person who likes to eat. So, the usability of the service matters just as much as the taste.

1. Sign Up: You pick your plan (2 people or 4 people) and how many meals you want per week.
2. Pick Your Meals: This is the hardest part because everything looks good. You can browse the menu here.
3. Delivery: The box arrives insulated and chilled. I left mine on the porch for 3 hours while I was at the gym, and the shrimp was still ice-cold when I opened it.
4. Cook: The recipe cards are huge, clear, and have pictures for every step.

This is what I was working with for my first meal. Look at how organized it is!

Pro Tip: Read the recipe card before you start the fire. Trust me on this one.

The Taste Test: Is It Actually Good?

Okay, let’s talk about the food. Because if it tastes like cardboard, who cares if Martha Stewart signed off on it?

I cooked the Steak & Brown Butter Sauce with Roasted Potatoes.

First off, “Brown Butter Sauce” sounded intimidating. But the instructions walked me through it, and oh my god? I wanted to drink it. The steak was tender, the potatoes were crispy, and the whole thing came together in about 35 minutes.

I mean, just look at this. I made this!

The Verdict on Taste: It’s significantly better than the “budget” meal kits. You can taste the difference in the sauces and the spice blends. It tastes like a $30 restaurant meal that you made in your pajamas.

The Pros and Cons (No Fluff)

I promised you an honest review, so here is the good, the bad, and the tasty.

The Good:

• The Variety: 100+ choices a week is insane. You will never get bored.
• The “Martha” Factor: The recipes actually teach you cooking techniques.
• The Convenience: No grocery shopping. Period.
• Sustainability: They are carbon-neutral, which makes the shipping feel less guilty.

The Not-So-Good:

• Packaging: Like all meal kits, there is plastic involved. They are getting better at using paper, but it’s still something to consider.
• Price: It is slightly more premium than the “budget” boxes. However, with the discount code below, it’s actually cheaper than buying groceries for the first few weeks.

The Cost (And How to Save Big)

Is it cheap? No. Is it worth it? Absolutely.

Normally, you’re paying for the convenience and the high-end ingredients. But, because we are best friends now, I hooked you up with a massive discount.

EXCLUSIVE OFFER: Get Up to $250 Off (First 6 Orders)

Use Code: 250MarleyBF2025

Final Verdict: Should You Buy It?

If you are tired of the “What’s for dinner?” mental load, want to eat better food, and want to actually enjoy cooking again… Yes.

Marley Spoon is the best option for people who love food but hate the hassle of meal planning. Treat yourself. Your stomach (and your sanity) will thank you.